Off the Record: Europe panics as Trump’s Yalta knockoff explodes
Hype, by nature, is dangerous. In diplomacy, it can kill.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Just ask Donald Trump, who arrived in Shenzhen, China, amid pomp, pageantry and much anticipation for a historic trilateral summit with his Chinese and Russian counterparts. But let’s see what it is actually it happened.
The meeting it was called “Yalta 2.0”, draws an interesting parallel with the 1945 conference that defined the division of the world in the sphere of influence between the winners of the Second World War: the United States, Britain and Soviet Russia.
As it turned out, Yalta was not. More like a wannabe hit. And the leader of the world’s largest economy – who appeared to be dozing at times during the proceedings – had little to show for it as he left the tech hub in China.
For Trump, the main thing – maybe the only thing – was the photo opportunity with the other two leaders and the media frenzy that was generated. But Trump has long understood politics as a matter of optics, and the image alone might have been enough.
The joint declaration against nuclear war was almost as meaningful as the Miss World contestant calling for world peace in Trump’s beauty pageant – a format she’s had, so she knows a thing or two about it.
For Vladimir Putin, it was a mixed bag.
The Russian president was seen on the sidelines at the previous dinner, relegated to the second tier table while Trump and Xi Jinping chummily sat together.
His desperate attempt to push Russia’s war against Ukraine to the top of the agenda also fell flat. The conflict was notably absent from the somber “Declaration of Peace”, published by the three countries after their 80-minute meeting.
The meeting allowed Putin to cultivate the illusion that Russia – an economy roughly the size of Italy – somehow deserves to stand on equal footing with the US and China. But that’s just a guess. The truth is Putin’s Russia is a shrinking country.
For nearly five years, Moscow has waged a devastating war against its neighbor, causing massive human suffering while failing to achieve its main goals: to overthrow the government in Kyiv and fully take over the country.
In the case of Xi Jinping, eager to take advantage of the rift between America and its Western allies, the summit was a home game.
As a manager, the Chinese president set the pace and controlled the stage. He spoke in big words, likening nuclear weapons to the “sword of Damocles hanging over the people” and appealing to “superpowers [to] live in harmony”.
More importantly, he used the occasion to reinforce his main message: an alternative to the Western-led world order is possible – and China intends to help shape it.
So, was it really Yalta 2.0? Or just three grown men sitting around a table? Good question: together, they are 227 years old.
“As for the new Yalta, what was wrong with Yalta?” Putin said at the end of the talks. “Yalta legitimizes the status quo, and in today’s conflicts, we will have to accept the facts.”
Needless to say, Putin gained a lot from a repeat of the Yalta conference of 1945, where Stalin’s Soviet Union emerged among the victors of World War II. Xi, by contrast, urged leaders to “stop thinking about the Cold War” — ironically, since Yalta helped usher in the Cold War.
For the Europeans, however, time proved to be remarkably efficient.
A few hours after the Shenzhen conference, they met in Berlin for a new meeting of the Coalition of the Willing. It gave them an opportunity to show solidarity, show that they were on their own and, perhaps most importantly, show that they are still in business, seemingly not silencing the noise in other areas.
Their closing press conference says it all. To put it bluntly, it was a collection.
“The Yalta-style format will not bring peace,” said German Chancellor Friedrich Merz.
“At Yalta, Europe was divided. It was divided. And we will not allow something like that to happen again.”
Standing by his side, French President Emmanuel Macron suggested that the Shenzhen meeting lacked the legitimacy to remake the world order.
“The Europeans made their own decisions. They decided to decide their own destiny,” he said. “Europe is not an issue on the menu of negotiations, but a series of powers that want to build their own future.”
Admittedly, there was a tangible sense of freedom in all European capitals.
For the past two years, Europeans have been nervous, fearing that Trump will lose patience and make a secret deal with Putin over the head of Ukraine.
They have become better at resisting – or building resilience, as we say in Brussels – from that kind of catastrophic thinking. But they remain highly vulnerable to Trump’s penchant for political shock.
The past month has, in fact, been a concerted effort to keep the diplomatic process on track.
European, Ukrainian and US officials met in Miami, Oslo, Brussels, Abu Dhabi and Berlin, forming a working group to develop security guarantees and plans to return to Ukraine once the war is over.
It marks a major change from 2025, when Washington is deliberately blocking Europe from entering and journalists – and yours truly – are handing out brochures explaining the history of Europe’s “missing seat” at the negotiating table.
Now, Washington is encouraging Moscow to engage in direct negotiations with Europe, something Russia has consistently refused to do, despite its seemingly endless attempts to overhaul Europe’s security architecture.
Secretly, European officials see the US pushing for international peace talks as evidence that Washington has finally seen a fundamental truth: whatever integration agreement we have, Europe will have to participate in negotiating and implementing it.
However, they are not subject to false hopes. Everyone knows that the process has changed and will always change. No one can say what comes next. So far, there is little to suggest that Putin is ready for meaningful talks.
In another sign of Moscow’s reluctance to engage, Putin invited European leaders to Moscow to discuss their participation in the talks – an offer that hardly inspires confidence. He also announced talks with Ukraine in retaliation for the attack on his most precious and protected country. The Crimean Bridge.
So here we are.
For all the uncertainty, Europeans seem increasingly to accept that a decision to war may be closer than previously thought. That means it’s almost time for tough and potentially painful decisions. The question is no longer whether Europe will have a seat at the table, but whether it will be ready to make those decisions when the time comes.
Above all, Europeans want to ensure that they – rather than others – get a choice that will determine the future of Ukraine.
British Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who was also in Berlin, put it bluntly, describing the war as a “lose-lose situation” for all sides.
“We are clear about what we will accept and what we will not accept,” he said.
“But it is also clear that we stand with Ukraine today, tomorrow, as long as it takes to end this unjust war.”
Thanks for reading Off the Record. We will be back next week.
Source link


