Wikipedia is often taken for granted – but its history is amazing, and its future is fragile | Richard Cooke

A few years ago, I was struck by the tension between how Wikipedia was used, and how it was talked about. Everyone was on it all the time, and yet its reputation was “don’t trust it”, because “it was a free encyclopedia that anyone could edit”.
Obviously people be to trust it, so much so that it had become part of the fabric of everyday life since it was founded by Jimmy Wales and Larry Sanger in 2001. But despite the fact it has now been shown billions of times by billions of people (the English Wikipedia alone is 5.2bn words long), it inspires a strange lack of curiosity. Even people who contribute to Wikipedia may claim that the money belongs to “fact checkers”, even though they are not – unpaid. In the meantime, the internet in the era of social media had started to feel like a terrible place, and some digital nostalgia was setting in: here is this problem that somehow survived; a website that works – and looks – like it did 20 years ago.
You could say I fell down the Wiki rabbit hole, especially when it comes to the early years of the website. Almost everything important about the project came together quickly. Its unconventional, home-grown behavior was unpopular with many writers and journalists, and that meant many questions about why it worked remained unanswered. Most of the people most interested in Wikipedia were the academic minority – so I decided to write a book about it.
I’m not a tech journalist. Instead, I have a human background. Wikipedia actually does, too: philosophy, as well as non-traditional disciplines such as urban planning and poetry, played a far greater role in its inception than pure technology. Ward Cunningham, who founded the wiki in the 1990s – that is a web page that anyone can edit, and the basic tool of Wikipedia – thought hard about how to democratize the power of computers. He has drawn on all sorts of ideas that lean towards it, such as constructivism and the Zen concept of wabi-sabi – the beauty of imperfection – and it’s amazing how far the culture he’s created has progressed. Especially wabi-sabi – Wikipedia, after all, is always in a state of imperfection.
Philosophy brought the founders of Wikipedia together. Although Wales worked in technology and finance, he corresponded with philosophers for years. And even though Sanger was an academic philosopher, he spent a lot of time arguing on the Internet – only “newbies” seemed to share his view that philosophy had life and death stakes. Many people in the dotcom boom started online encyclopedias, but Wales was the only one to hire a philosopher. In fact i only the person he hired was a philosopher. It was an unexpected choice, and an important clue to what made Wikipedia work: it came out of this digital “republic of letters”, where all kinds of people thought about facts and why they mattered.
Because Wikipedia is so large, writing a “complete” book on it is impossible, like trying to represent a mountain with a grain of sand. Instead, I focused on human history – the small, sometimes very small, number of people who really influenced what Wikipedia became. Wikipedians can be tough, and the worst ones get a bad rap – even the leadership of the Wikimedia Foundation has commented on their “Dorito-stained fingers”, or tendency to stay home on Saturday nights. But by the end of the program, I was afraid of them, and I still am.
Wales and Sanger are prominent, but many other early Wikipedians are unknown. The first woman to edit Wikipedia, Gaytha Langlois, is largely overlooked. He wrote about two of his favorite things: Rhode Island and standard poodles – small dogs and large dogs. Wikipedia has always had a gender imbalance, which has proven stubborn – Sandi Toksvig is just the latest in a long line of critics trying to fix it. He is part of an effort to create a balanced alternative to Wikipedia called Mappa Mundi, which has the power to link back to Wikipedia as well.
I was also intrigued by a lesser-known offering who had the first female biography page on Wikipedia (today, it would be called a user page). Her name was Ruth Ifcher, and she was a brilliant grammar student, with a PhD, who had been forced out of her job due to severe agoraphobia. Wikipedia appeared later in his life and opened a new way of doing creative and meaningful work.
Proust said that neurotics alone “composed our works of art” and that is true here.
Neurodiversity is so central to Wikipedia that one former head of the Wikimedia Foundation told me that the encyclopedia is “a city built by Aspergers”. You can feel that energy in familiar topics – airplanes, trains and cars, comic books, the weather, and everything else. In general, Wikipedias are expanding so much that they write a lot, something called “fancruft”. “Road experts” (like road trainspotters) kept deleting their work about minor roads, so many of them were left confused, and started a separate online wiki encyclopedia of roads. That’s probably a microcosm of the inclusionists v deletionists debate, which is the biggest philosophical divide in Wikipedia – an ongoing debate about what should be included, and what shouldn’t be included.
The co-founders once believed that 100,000 titles would be a “reasonable size” for an encyclopedia, given how large the Britannica was. Today, Wikipedia has 68m, and Pew Research estimates that it will have served 1.9tn page views between 2015 and 2025. Because it is so big, I never expected that Wikipedia would feel weak or vulnerable – but as I finished this book, AI had started to enter Wikipedia in an existing way by reducing the number of web editors, or reducing the capacity of the web. poorly generated AI text. People ask me “is Wikipedia in danger?”, and it is, but so is everything from Hollywood to pure mathematics. I think it will survive, but the shaky foundations made it urgent to say “we’ve seen this done, and we’ll never see the like of it again”.
-
The Internet’s Best Last Place: Wikipedia’s Personal History by Richard Cooke is out now via Black Inc in Australia, and WW Norton in the US. It will be released in the UK on 5 November, via Granta



