World

A Florida couple defaulted on four mortgage payments and stopped paying in 2017; the appeals court renewed the foreclosure proceedings despite the bank’s accounting errors

Featured Image (AI-generated)

A mortgage dispute can be complicated when a lender’s accounting records leave borrowers questioning how much they owe. A Florida couple faced this situation after their bank canceled four mortgage payments they made in 2015 without explaining why. Although they continued to make monthly payments for nearly two more years, the lender eventually refused to accept any more payments, and the couple stopped making payments. The dispute finally reached the Court of Appeal after the judge ruled that the bank failed to prove that it had paid the money.In a November 4, 2026 opinion, Florida’s Second Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that decision in The Bank of New York Mellon v. Fernandez, case number 2D2025-1819. This decision, obtained from Justia, renewed the bankruptcy case against Michael and Dianna Fernandez. However, the court also ordered the lower court to exclude the four disputed payments and certain interest related fees when calculating the debt owed.

Four mortgage payments were waived

Michael and Dianna Fernandez signed a deed for a $160,000 mortgage in 2007, securing their home. In 2012, they filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy and subsequently entered into a mortgage modification agreement with the loan servicer. At the time, Bank of America was servicing the Bank of New York Mellon loan. On August 21, 2015, the bank canceled four mortgage payments the couple had made earlier that year, between January and April.However, the payment records did not explain why the transaction was reversed. At the trial, the bank’s representative could not give an exact reason and could only speculate about the circumstances that could cause such a reversal. Dianna revealed that she had paid all four of them and the money was never returned to her. The loan deferment has put four loan payments behind schedule, according to bank records. Despite this, the couple continued to make monthly payments from August 2015 to April 2017, and the bank accepted them.The situation changed in May 2017, when Bank of America returned its payment because it was not enough to cover the amount the bank wanted it to owe, including four canceled payments. Dianna also visited the bank branch about twice that month to make the payment, but the bank refused to accept it.

The bank has filed foreclosure proceedings

In 2017, the bank first filed a foreclosure lawsuit but voluntarily dismissed it before trial. In January 2021, it filed another foreclosure action, saying the couple hadn’t been paid since January 1, 2017, and all subsequent installments. The Fernandezes denied the allegations, saying that they paid until the bank stopped accepting them. They also emphasized that the borrower’s actions are what caused the alleged non-payment.During the bench trial, Dianna admitted that the last payment received by the couple was made in April 2017. She also admitted that they had not made any payments and did not have enough money to cover the mortgage when the new foreclosure action was filed. The court judge found in favor of the couple, finding that the bank failed to establish the debt. The judge relied on the mysterious cancellation of the previous four payments, Dianna’s credible testimony and the bank’s decision to return the May 2017 payment and reject subsequent payment attempts. The bank appealed the decision.

The appeals court found that the later missed payments proved to be a failure

The appeals court agreed that the bank had failed to explain the four withdrawn payments. However, it found that this accounting problem did not end the couple’s separate obligation to continue making monthly payments. The majority stated that the undisputed evidence shows that the couple did not pay from June 2017 onwards. Each missed monthly installment created a separate default under Florida law.The court explained that disagreements about how the borrower pays off do not automatically give borrowers a chance to continue fulfilling their loan obligations. Even if the previous four payments were improperly withdrawn, the couple still had to pay the next one. The court also dismissed the couple’s argument that the bank’s refusal to accept payments amounts to unclean hands. It has found sufficient evidence of fraud, dishonesty or wrongdoing to legally prevent the bank from pursuing foreclosure.The majority also noted that the couple did not legally discharge their unpaid arrears by filing with the court or by showing that they had the money due at the time of the lawsuit.

The forfeiture case was sent back for further proceedings

The Florida Court of Appeals reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded the case for further proceedings. It ordered the lower court to remove the principal amount of the four deferred payments, the interest earned before June 2017 and any fees charged before July 2017. The court also allowed the lower court to consider a reduction in attorneys’ fees for work performed in opposition to the four waived payments. Judge Silberman disagreed, saying the trial court’s findings were supported by the evidence. He went on to say that the bank’s mysterious withdrawal of funds, return of payment and refusal to accept subsequent installments have effectively created and increased long-term repayment.This decision does not mean that the couple lost their home immediately. It reverses bankruptcy procedures while requiring disputed accounting entries and associated costs to be excluded from the liability calculation. The appeals court also noted that the couple could still explore options to keep their assets, including bailing out the mortgage under Florida law or pursuing available federal bankruptcy protections.


Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button