A woman earns Rs 6.7 lakh, including Rs 3.9 lakh short-term benefits; taxpayer rejects Rs 25,000 Section 87A deduction under new regime, claims tax of Rs 75,502; ITAT gives relief, but deduction is applicable this year

Are your short-term capital gains also eligible for rebate if your net income falls below Rs 12 lakh? A taxpayer who made short-term gains on listed shares won an argument for an income tax rebate of Rs 25,000 after the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Hyderabad, ruled in his favour.The decision of the ITAT was regarding the availability of deduction under Section 87A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (‘the Act’), against the tax payable on short-term gains arising from the transfer of equity shares taxable under Section 111A of the Act.In its order dated November 6, 2026, the court ruled that Section 87A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, did not expressly disallow deduction in cases where the income includes short-term benefits taxed at a special rate under Section 111A. However, there is a catch.
What is the case about
The woman filed her tax return for the assessment year 2025-26, declaring an income of Rs 6,77,511. This includes short-term capital gains of Rs 3,97,511 from transfer of listed equity shares. Such benefits are taxable u/s 111A of the Act at a special rate of tax.He opted for the new tax regime under Section 115BAC(1A) and claimed a deduction of Rs 25,000 under Section 87A. However, when the Centralized Processing Center (CPC), Bengaluru, processed his return, it fixed the tax payable at Rs 75,502 without allowing any deduction.The assessee challenged the denial before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). The first appellate officer rejected his explanation and agreed with his denial. He then approached the Hyderabad bench of the ITAT.His learned counsel contended that neither Section 87A nor Section 115BAC(1A) expressly barred the deduction merely because part of the taxpayer’s income was taxable under Section 111A.The representative also relied on two previous court decisions: Jayshreeben Jayantibhai Palsana v. ITOdecided by the ITAT Ahmedabad bench, and Pushpa Prakash Misar v. ITOdecided by the ITAT Mumbai bench. Jayendran’s lawyer also cited the decision of the Bombay High Court Chamber of Tax Consultants v. DGIT (Systems).The Revenue opposed the application. Its representative relied on CBD Circular No. 13/2025, dated September 19, 2025, and argued that the discount was not applicable to taxpayers who chose the new tax system under Section 115BAC(1A). The department maintains that the lower authorities have properly dismissed the request.
Why did ITAT rule in favor of assessment?
Tanu Gupta, Partner at Mainstay Tax Advisors LLP says this decision is important in interpreting Section 87A and the extent to which the rebate can be prohibited by Circular No. 13/2025 dated September 19, 2025 issued by the CBD.“The ITAT was of the view that the AO and the CIT(A) had no other reason for disallowing the tax deduction u/s 87A of the Act on the tax liability including short term capital gains tax u/s 111A at a special rate,” he said.Further, looking at the plain language of Section 87A and its provisions, the ITAT was of the view that there is no limitation to claim deduction u/s.87A of the Act where the assessee satisfies other prescribed conditions, such as income below the applicable limit even if it includes income tax at a special rate under Section 111A of the Act.“The decision of the Tribunal is based on the previous decisions, it was said that there is no specific limitation for claiming rebate u/s.87A of the Act even in cases of payment of tax under the new taxation law as per the provisions of Sec.115BAC(1A) of the Act,” Gupta told TOI.“This decision is a welcome development for taxpayers, especially in the previous assessment years, as it clarifies that the eligibility of the tax rebate should be determined based on the provisions of the Income Tax Act and not limited by administrative circulars or changes in the return filing process. It also emphasizes the principle that the circular cannot take away the benefit available under the Act,” he added.However, the Guptas cautioned that taxpayers should be aware that the position changes from FY 2025-26 onwards, as the Finance Act, 2025 has restricted the Section 87A deduction for tax calculated at specified slab rates. “Therefore, the rebate will no longer be available against the tax payable on income at a special rate, including temporary capital gains under Section 111A,” he concluded.Therefore, even though the ITAT ruled in favor of the assessee for that assessment year, the taxpayers should not consider that this deduction is no longer applicable from this year.
Source link
