AI steals Australian indigenous art and produces ‘Temu slop’, says artist | Traditional art

AI is taking First Nations art and turning it into “Temu slop”, says Pitjantjatjara artist Sally Scales.
Scales, chairman of the advisory group for the National Gallery of First Nations of Australia, said the technology undermines the agency of First Nations artists and the authenticity of their work and represents a “theft” of cultural knowledge.
Despite prime minister Anthony Albanese’s pledge to protect Australian inventors from copyright theft, and the attorney general, Michelle Rowland, saying “there are no plans to weaken copyright protection”, AI has already been trained – without compensation – in the works of well-known Australian artists including Kylie Minogue and Nick Cave.
But experts are more concerned about the dangers of indigenous cultural and intellectual property (ICIP) and a world where AI companies can compile anything that can be found on the Internet, including songs and paintings that include sacred and cultural information. AI has changed work, removed names and sold it, a move an Australian visual artists’ group says is causing “cultural and economic damage”.
A search on sites including Temu, Shein and Amazon reveals dozens of works described as Aboriginal paintings, as well as items such as coasters and coasters with Aboriginal-style designs, mostly without attribution to any artist.
“It’s in the name, it’s artificial,” Scales said.
“I have seen other works where I look and wonder if they have gone through a First Nations community or a person, or if it is a normal thing they have beaten.
“Stealing the artist’s agency. It destroys its authenticity, because no one is involved… the artist’s family is not there, the experience is not there.”
Professor Kathy Bowrey, an intellectual property expert from UNSW Law, said one in five creators already have copyright infringement issues outside of AI. But he added that the problems became more complicated when the creators were First Nations people, “in part because of the lack of control over ownership and respect for Aboriginal culture”.
He gave the example of an organization paying to use artwork or images of Indigenous people themselves, then later using AI to “update” or reuse those images without permission.
“A customer can pay you once and then do unauthorized Aboriginal work and use the artists’ faces without permission,” he said.
“Not only doing [the artists] who don’t get repeat business, but when they go to do new work they compete with AI.”
The National Association for the Visual Arts (Nava) said Aboriginal data sovereignty “recognizes the right of First Nations people to exercise authority over their data, cultural materials and information”.
In the proposal for the investigation of the selected committee on artificial intelligence, Nava pointed to the work of Wuthathi and Meriam lawyer Terri Janke, an international authority on cultural property and indigenous intellectuals, who “documented an AI that destroys the websites of the indigenous art center, removing the names of artists and changing their work”.
Janke also warned of the broader risk of AI reproducing cultural knowledge without regard to its accuracy or appropriate use.
“Nava members have also expressed concern about AI-generated ‘Native style’ images and designs that mimic community-specific techniques, stories, motifs and mark-making,” the submission said. “These images can be presented and sold as Indigenous or Aboriginal work, spreading false information, causing cultural and economic harm and competing with the work of First Nations artists.”
Bowrey and his colleague, associate professor of creative technology Oliver Bown, have proposed what they call the Copyright Plus framework, which would give creators more power over the use of their work by forcing AI companies to disclose their data sources and giving artists the right to refuse to have their work copied or copied. They also proposed a tax on AI companies to create a system to pay innovation experts and create a cultural fund, as well as the use of takedown notices for fake content.
Bowrey said they wrote the draft policy based on the limitations of what the government has said so far.
A spokeswoman for the attorney-general said Australian inventors were “world-class” and that the government was committed to supporting them.
“That’s why we continue to engage with creators, media organizations and AI companies about a range of options to ensure that any future copyright changes deliver reasonable control and fair compensation,” the spokesperson said.



