The man sold the house but did not file the ITR and when he got the tax notice he said he was exempted for Rs 49 lakh, but the taxman denied it; ITAT Mumbai has given relief that loss of actual returnable tax alone cannot close the door to Section 54

Can you claim exemption from your tax return if you did not file it initially and started filing ITR only after receiving notice from the Tax Department?In a relief to the taxpayers, the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled that the claim for exemption under Section 54 of the Income Tax (IT) Act for reinvestment of capital gains in a new house cannot be rejected because the taxpayer did not initially file an income tax return.The court held that such a claim can be considered and allowed if it is made at the time of reassessment.
What is the case about
The case concerned a single taxpayer who did not file a preliminary income tax return under Section 139(1).The dispute concerns the assessment year 2017-18. According to the court’s order, the Revenue Department had information that the man had purchased an immovable property worth Rs 45 lakh during the relevant year. Since he has not filed his income tax return, proceedings were initiated under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act. Notification under Section 148 was issued on March 24, 2024.The man filed his petition after the notice on April 4, 2024. In it, he sought exemption under Section 54 of the capital gain from the sale of the residence. The sale agreement was dated.In his ITR, the man reported long-term gains from the sale of residential property and claimed exemption of Rs 49 lakh under Section 54, citing his investment in another residential property.Section 54 of the Act allows people to claim exemption from long-term gains from the sale of a residence until the gains are reinvested in the purchase of another residence within a specified period.The assessing officer rejected the claim of the assessee, citing the absence of original income tax return.The assessment order referred to Section 54D while disallowing the claim made under Section 54, and added Rs 31,38,256 to his income.The man contested the addition before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), but the appellate authority upheld the decision. It depended on the decision of the Supreme Court CIT vs Sun Engineering Works (P.) Ltd.which addresses limitations on the claims that can be raised during the reassessment process.
Why ITAT Mumbai has decided in favor of the assessee
The ITAT Mumbai clarified that while reassessment proceedings cannot be used to reopen matters unrelated to income that escapes assessment, taxpayers can raise claims directly linked to that income.The ITAT observed that the main benefit in this case was unassessed income, making the claim for exemption under Section 54 directly relevant to the computation of that income.The order explains that the escaped income in this case was a long-term capital gain from the sale of the residence. The Section 54 claim relates to the computation of that very income and was not an unrelated claim raised at the time of reassessment.It therefore held that the claim for relief could not be classified as a new or unrelated claim which was invalid during the review proceedings.The court also cited previous judicial decisions that stated that Section 54 does not make filing the tax return by the due date a mandatory condition for claiming exemption. It emphasized that a claim filed in response to a reassessment notice cannot be rejected simply because it was filed late or the taxpayer did not file an actual return.The order also records that, in a case involving a husband’s wife, the assessing officer allowed the Section 54 deduction claimed by the return form filed in response to the reassessment notice for the remaining 50% of the investment in the new property. The court saw this situation when considering the man’s argument.In its reasoning, the court held that prior decisions supported allowing the claim to be evaluated rather than dismissing it because no original return had been filed. It concluded: “Therefore, respectfully relying on the above judgments we are inclined to allow the appeal of the Assessee and, therefore, remand the case to the file of the AO to decide afresh the claim of the Assessee under section 54 of the Act within the limits and/or conditions laid down in section 54 of the Act but not otherwise.“The ITAT then set aside the orders passed by the lower authorities and remanded the case back to the assessing officer for reconsideration.Direct the officer to assess the taxpayer’s eligibility for the Section 54 exemption on merit and grant the benefit if the applicable statutory requirements are met.
Source link
