‘They have plans to follow’: how fast boats are threatening endangered whales in the Mediterranean | Whales

Mmarine biologist Alice Barbarioli waits with her camera trained on the horizon. A few minutes earlier, a hydrophone on the bottom of the research vessel Pelagos detected codas – a sequence of clicks that sperm whales use to communicate.
The sperm whale reveals its head and dorsal fin as those who board the boat in the sanctuary of Pelagos, a conservation area established to protect marine mammals in the northwest Mediterranean, rush to take pictures and note the rhythm of its breathing. After a few minutes, the animal bends its back, and begins to return to the depths of the sea. They waited to see its tail.
Barbarioli, lead researcher on the citizen science expedition, organized by the Tethys Research Institute, immediately notices the damage of the left fluke: “Given how accurate the sign is, maybe the result of [vessel] conflict,” he said.
Collisions have long been recognized as the leading cause of death for sperm whales in the Mediterranean. Now, a Guardian investigation using data from the maritime intelligence company Veson Nautical, has found that large passenger and cargo ships operated by four companies – Grimaldi Group, Corsica Ferries, Baleària and Moby Lines – often travel in the protected area that includes the sanctuary of Pelagos at 15 knots (17 meters mph or more) almost every time in cases of murder. Strikes are unlikely to be fatal if the ship is traveling at less than 10 knots.
Slow-moving vessels are the most effective means of mitigation where transport is not possible, according to conservation NGO Oceancare.
The sea between Valencia and Genoa, which includes the Pelagos sanctuary, is a prime cetacean habitat, home to almost two-thirds of the Mediterranean whales and more than a fifth of the sperm whales. In July 2023, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) created the Northwest Mediterranean Sea Area (PSSA). In the voluntary speed recommendation (VSR), it advised vessels of 300 tonnes and above to travel at 10 to 13 knots in the area to reduce the risk of fatal collisions.
Without recommending IMO, the Guardian, uses more data from Global Fishing Watch, found that vessels with IMO numbers spent more than 280,000 hours sailing at 15 knots and above with PSSA by 2025. It builds on previous reviews that found voluntary recommendations were ineffective.
In 2022 and 2025, the boats owned by the Grimaldi Group, including the Cruise Roma – at more than 250 meters, the longest boat in the world – dominated the list of 20 ships that spend most of their time at 15 knots or more at sea.
The speed remained fixed among the few PSSA operators in 2025, with only seven ships – four Baleària fast boats and three Grimaldi cruise boats – responsible for 70% of the hours spent above 25 knots. The seven Grimaldi cruise ships reached almost 8% of all hours recorded by all ships at 15 knots or more in 2025.
The Guardian has spoken to six captains – five current and one former PSSA captain since it was appointed. The maritime workers, who still manage Grimaldi Group and Moby Lines ships, say their companies have not introduced measures to encourage slow sailing after the IMO’s VSR.
“If it’s only recommendations, no one will slow down,” said another Grimaldi captain. “It will mean fixing the entire commercial system, the boats in this area leave at 25 [knots]especially those that carry tourists. They have plans to follow.”
Grimaldi and Moby Lines were contacted for comment but did not respond.
Thomas Folegot, CEO of the marine technology company Quiet-Oceans, says that although the slow container ships can withstand the reduced speed in the PSSA, it has been a big challenge for the boats: “For their business, it is fatal. [Passengers] he will fly to Corsica.”
An analysis by Quiet-Oceans and Oceancare found that 80% of merchant shipping in the PSSA by 2023 was traveling at speeds above 10 knots.
Simone Panigada, president of the Tethys Research Institute and chairman of the scientific committee dedicated to the conservation of cetaceans, says it’s time to “move, little by little, from voluntary to mandatory rules” to reduce the risk of collisions.
“A binding framework can create better conditions for all operators, encourage compliance between shipping companies and ensure the adoption of these measures does not depend on the decisions of each company,” he said.
The International Whaling Commission (IWC) told the Guardian it had recorded six incidents since July 2023 in the PSSA: five near misses and one collision. It believes that many strikes are not recorded.
Although the annual time spent in PSSA above the critical limit of 15 knots remains high in 2025, it represents an 11% decrease compared to 2022. Time above 25 knots also decreased by almost a third between 2022 and 2025.
The decline is likely to be due to factors including altered shipping routes, says Olivia Watkins, assistant director at Veson Nautical, who adds: “The PSSA recommendation is unlikely to be the main cause of the year-on-year decline in data results.”
Wei-Jun Mun, director of public policy at the World Shipping Council, says the industry is committed to the PSSA’s safeguards, while noting that slow shipping involves “commercial trade-offs and operational concerns”, including adding ships to service to remain reliable.
A spokesperson for Corsica Ferries says the company is supporting research on Mediterranean marine life and reducing ship strikes through measures including ongoing monitoring, crew training and the development of whale warning equipment. It says researchers from programs including the conservation project Life Conceptu Maris monitor wildlife using their ships.
The company says it advises captains to carefully check the PSSA, and reduce speed to 10 to 13 knots, “trying to avoid the potential adverse effects of reduced speed”, including displacement. It says its captains reported a reduced capacity to avoid cetaceans suddenly appearing when traveling at reduced speed.
A spokesman for Baleària says it is “committed to preserving marine biodiversity” and is actively working to reduce the risk of collisions, including staff training and the use of real-time monitoring systems to allow captains to adjust speed and course where necessary. Baleària says none of its speedboats have recorded collisions with cetaceans.
Baleària adds that it participates in marine conservation programs, including the Life Conceptu Maris and Life Intemares programs.

