An Arkansas homeowner says a neighbor’s fence moved down a tunnel from 20 to eight feet, preventing him from driving his cart around his home; the appeals court overturned the earlier decision

An Arkansas homeowner says his neighbor reached out and stopped him from driving his wagon around his house. Now he has won an appeal after the high court overturned an earlier ruling on the world war. The fence change reduced the space between the fence and his mailbox from about 20 feet down to just eight feet. That small space made it difficult for him to go out to the county road. The Arkansas Court of Appeals reversed a Boone County Circuit Court decision in favor of the neighbor, Bob Robertson, and the Bob Robertson Family Limited Partnership. In a written decision issued on November 18, 2026, the appeals court said the lower court applied the wrong rules when deciding several aspects of the land and road dispute. Roger C. Moore filed the lawsuit. He revealed that he has used the disputed area for many years to turn his 18-foot trailer while hauling hay and wood. He also fought his neighbor’s use of the shared road when they visited the tolls, and a lower court order forcing him to rebuild the old fence. According to the decision posted by Justia, the appeals court sent the case back to Boone County Circuit Court for a new trial. It told the lower court to reconsider Moore’s right to use a narrow passage, property lines between two neighbors, and how both parties can use the shared road.
A dispute over an old farm road
This property war goes back many decades. According to the Arkansas Court of Appeals, Moore and the Robertsons own properties in Boone County. Both properties were part of Charlotte and Johnny Ray Barnes’ large estate. In 1974, the Barnes family sold 40 acres to Lorene and Michael Roberts, who owned the land before Moore. The deed to the property included a right of way along the south end. The ordinance allowed the owners of both neighborhoods to drive on the existing road.Moore purchased the 40-acre property from the Roberts family in 1987. He testified in court that the gate was already standing on the other side of the road when he bought the property. He also said that he used to use the road in front of his house as his road, going down it to reach the stream and feed his cattle. The neighborhood changed hands in 1976, when Delbert Tharp bought a large property from the Barnes family. Later, in September 2012, the Bob Robertson Family Limited Partnership purchased the property from the Tharp family.Ty Robertson, Bob Robertson’s son, testified that he began helping Tharp with farm work in 2008. He said two fences ran along the road, with gates at both ends of the property near Moore’s property. Those sites formed a route that worked well for grazing cattle. Ty also told the court that the west gate was always locked and he did not see Moore using that part of the road. According to his testimony, Moore did not receive the key after purchasing the land.
A wire extension blocked access to the trailer
Moore told the court that Bob Robertson extended the fence on the western edge of his land in late 2013 or early 2014. New gates were installed at the same time. According to Moore, these changes prevented him from driving his 18-foot trailer around his house to get to the county road like he used to. He said he asked Robertson to leave enough space for his truck to pass while the new fence went up, but Robertson didn’t listen. Moore stated that he has been using the open space between his house and the old western fence since 1987. He always needed that room when he hauled loads of hay and wood. He also said he mowed and tended his yard all the way to the county road, and used that area as a turning point for years.The battle took a turn for the worse in 2018 when the Robertsons opened a travel business called Hog Wild Adventures. They began to pick up paying tourists across their territory in foreign vehicles. Those hiking trails go down the street in front of Moore’s house. Moore complained that the extra traffic brought more noise and dust, and wore down the road. In November 2018, Moore tore down the north fence that ran along the road. Later that month, Ty Robertson came down the west gate. Moore sued on February 5, 2019. He asked the court to declare the south telephone line as the original property line, restore the gates, and stop the Robertsons from blocking his access to the street. He also demanded that the west fence be restored to its original location, and asked the court to limit the shared road to the old farm.
The lower court found in favor of the neighbor
The Robertsons have denied Moore’s claims. They complain that they got the legal ownership of the disputed land through illegal acquisition, a law where a person takes ownership by using the land openly for years. They also said Moore waived his rights because he was not using the road regularly. After a trial, the Boone County District Court issued its decision on December 12, 2024. The judge designated the old north fence as the true boundary between the two properties and ruled that the Robertsons now owned the disputed parcel by adverse possession. The lower court also ruled that Moore waived his right of entry because he allowed neighbors to install locks on the west gates. The judge ordered Moore to pay to rebuild the north fence, and prohibited him from using the road or entering the Robertsons’ driveway. The court also rejected his request to have an alternative driveway placed along the west fence, ruling that he waited too long to ask for the old fence to be returned. Moore appealed that decision, mounting nine separate legal challenges.
The appeals court finds errors in the earlier decision
The Arkansas Court of Appeals reviewed the lower court’s decision and sided with Moore on several key points. First, the appeals judges ruled that the Robertsons did not properly plead their claim that the two parties had agreed to treat the northern line as a local line. Because it was left out of their court papers, the lower court could not use them.The appeals judges also overturned the decision that the Robertsons won the disputed road and land due to wrongful possession. They explained that the evidence does not show seven years of hatred, as the law requires. The court also pointed out that there was no evidence that the Robertsons or the previous owners had been paying the required property tax on the disputed or neighboring land for seven years. In addition, the appeals court ruled that Moore did not waive his legal rights simply because his neighbors locked their gates.The justices also questioned the lower court’s decision to allow recreational vehicles on the shared road without carefully examining the original 1974 deed and how both owners had used the road in the past. The appeals court emphasized that the lower court should weigh the rights of both neighbors accordingly, instead of looking only at how the Robertsons wanted to use the road.
The court orders a review of trailer access
The appeals court considered Moore’s claim that the extended west fence blocked his carriage. The judges found that the lower court applied the wrong legal test when it denied his request for disclosure of the judgment. That is the legal right to continue using someone else’s land after doing so openly for a long time. The lower court forced Moore to testify that he was the only person using the disputed clip. The appeals court explained that the statute is about continuous, ongoing use, not just ownership or control of the land, so special use is not required.The high court also rejected a claim that Moore waited too long to ask for the old fence to be put back. The judges noted that the Robertsons failed to show that they made changes based on Moore’s delay. In addition, Moore testified that he spoke at the same time that the fence was extended. Because of these errors, the appellate court overturned the lower court’s decision and remanded the case for reconsideration.In the new proceedings, the Boone County Circuit Court must reconsider Moore’s right to drive along the west fence, decide whether the old fence should be moved back, and set appropriate rules for how the two neighbors can share the road. Judge Mike Murphy wrote the opinion dated November 18, 2026, and Judges Abramson and Barrett concurred. This appeals court decision does not draw a final territorial line or affirm Moore’s current access, but it forces the lower court to decide those questions using the appropriate legal rules.
Source link

