‘No time for a culture war’: Victoria’s electricity supply is at risk. Can it avoid energy shortages and credit shocks? | 2026 Victorian state election

Victoria’s electricity supply will be at risk when a major power station closes in 2028 and no major party is offering a plan in this month’s state election to deal with it, experts have warned.
All parties agree that the giant Yallourn coal plant, which has operated in the Latrobe Valley since the 1970s and provides a fifth of Victoria’s energy, is at the end of its life and will close in less than two years. Analysts say that the parties running for government failed to properly explain how they will turn off the electricity that will be caused by the shutdown.
The challenge facing Victoria is exacerbated by the growing demand for electricity in information centers and the electrification of buildings, homes and vehicles. Experts are highly critical of the Coalition, led by Liberal leader Jess Wilson, who is tipped to win. It says it will halt work on new transmission lines – high-voltage power lines needed to connect new wind and solar farms and allow Victoria to import electricity into neighboring states.
Tim Baxter, of Naru Research, says there is no “time for a culture and power war in Victoria” because the wrong choice now could be “dangerous” to the state’s economy and cause credit shock to households and businesses.
He says cheap gas helped build Victoria’s previous prosperity, but it is quickly fading with onshore gas from the Bass Strait in deep decline. And there is no evidence that the state has viable gas sources elsewhere to replace it. This has contributed to a 62% increase in gas prices in five years, he says, while electricity bills have increased by 18%.
With Victorians relying more on electricity than other states, Baxter says he is stressing the need for households to switch off gas and continue to use renewable energy. “Every windfarm, solar farm and battery that comes online before 2028 reduces how much expensive gas Victoria has to burn when Yallourn goes. That makes speed building the single best way to protect homes from high debt,” he said.
What do Labor and Coalition promise?
Victoria’s wholesale electricity prices are the lowest on the east coast, but households still rely heavily on expensive electricity. Regardless of who wins, energy bills are likely to rise, according to a government briefing reported in the Herald Sun.
The Coalition says it will scrap VNI West, a transmission line connecting Victoria and New South Wales, and temporarily suspend work on the Western Renewables Link, between Melbourne and the state’s west. Instead, it will conduct a “short, rigorous and independent” review of the state’s electricity transmission system, which could consider alternatives, such as commercial and industrial rooftop solar.
It also promised to “open the doors to gas audits”, reverse Labor’s policy to make new homes all electric, and tender for new energy with an Energy Security Requirement modeled on the NSW and South Australian plans. There is no plan to change the government’s emissions reduction targets – to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 75%–80% below 2005 levels by 2035 and to net zero by 2045. – but he has not said how he will achieve it.
Labor says it will continue to expand the electricity grid, move homes from gas to electricity for heating and cooking and continue to support the development of offshore wind farms. But the Carroll government is also reviewing the Western Renewables Link. It recently canceled a renewable energy zone, approved two gas developments (although one has gone into administration), and announced $7.5m to start a “renewable gas plant”.
Nexa Advisory CEO Stephanie Bashir says the new transmission is critical to developing renewable energy and allowing power to be imported across country routes in times of peak demand, such as during heat waves. “This is not the time to cancel any ongoing project,” he said. “This is the time when we put our foot on the accelerator and work hard.”
Environment Victoria chief executive Jono La Nauze says the Coalition’s plan – which includes a proposal to roll back a policy introduced by the previous Baillieu-Napthine Coalition government to ban wind turbines from being built within 2km of residential areas – is “the biggest fraud ever attempted on Victorian voters”.
“The coalition promises to stop all the necessary things instead of generating coal and gas. They have quick slogans about how they will rely on gas, they have nothing at all,” he said.
But analysts say Labor is also not building energy infrastructure fast enough.
after the promotion of the newsletter
Oliver Nunn, managing director of consultancy Endgame Analytics, says that the lack of an adequate strategy to prevent energy shortages means that “anyone who succeeds [the election]we lose”.
“You can see the demand for electricity rising rapidly in Victoria, growing by 5% year on year,” Nunn said. “Coal will go out, and right now we don’t have a plan that really works.”
In 12 years in government, Labor oversaw an increase in Victoria’s share of renewable energy from 10% to 44% and the closure of the main Hazelwood power station. The number of wind farms increased from 14 to 44 and large solar farms from two to 57. Labor also ended the state’s moratorium on regular gas testing in 2021.
But the state’s auditor general says both VNI West and the Western Renewables Link are behind schedule, and likely won’t be completed until after the planned closure of Yallourn.
Recent attempts to speed up the process by legislating compulsory land acquisition before environmental approval have been unpopular with regional communities, but Labor says the changes were needed to reduce delays and improve certainty for landowners. In opposition, Labor also passed legislation to allow VicGrid and its contractors to access private land without landowner permission, as a last resort to ease the work.
“Every time the government seems to hit an obstacle, what they have done is not go back and re-analyze the negotiation and try to fix it, what they have done is to change the law to give them broad powers,” said the president of the Victorian Farmers Federation, Ryan Milgate.
The energy minister, David Davis, calls the rules “double bazooka power” and says the Coalition will scrap them and restore landowners’ rights of appeal.
But Nexa’s Bashir says energy policy should not be a “political football”.
“We need to support the next generation. We can’t do any more revisions; we have to get on with it.”
Source link
