The listing will change Tata’s approach, putting profit above philanthropy: Noel

MUMBAI: Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata has stepped up his opposition to a possible listing of Tata Sons, saying bringing in public shareholders could upend the century-old ownership where philanthropy trumps profit.“My concern is that the listing, which is what some people are proposing, will change the way Tata works. And one day, if we have 30,000, 40,000 shares, profit may come before social welfare. I think that would change the way Tata operates.”Placing this issue as the core of the group’s identity, Tata added: “The totality of the Tata Group today is that 66% of Tata Sons’ profits are used for charitable purposes. That is unique in the world.”“Charity precedes commerce. Charity runs commerce. There is no other way,” he said at the HT Leadership Summit on Saturday.This comes as Tata Sons faces pressure to comply with India’s non-banking financial company (UL-NBFC) rules, which require a holding company to list. Tata Sons remains the only entity in the RBI’s list of UL-NBFCs that has not complied with the framework.Although Tata has publicly opposed the listing, other trustees of Tata Trusts have taken the opposite view. Trust vice-chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh argued that listing and philanthropy could coexist, citing global companies owned by foundations such as Novo Nordisk and Hershey. They argue that listing would not reduce the Trusts’ controlling stake and would strengthen governance, transparency and accountability while improving the distribution of charitable contributions.The difference underscores the unusual social divide between the Trusts. Noel succeeded Ratan Tata after his death in October 2024, and the debate exposed flaws in the future ownership structure of the $180 billion group.“Partitions from some of the companies on our list, which come through the channel, become tomorrow’s hospitals, tomorrow’s floods, tomorrow’s educational institutions, tomorrow’s relief for people in trouble,” said Tata. “This benefit becomes, in a sense, a public benefit. It repeats every year, year after year, by design.”Defending the existing structure, he said: “This time the owner does not die, the owner is not bought. The owner will not retire. Therefore, there is a continuation of Tata’s way.”Some trustees, however, maintain that Tata Sons’ shareholdings are held by charities and that the trustees act only as trustees and trustees, not owners.Tata also said that going private gives Tata Sons the ability to support group companies in times of need.“One thing that remains a secret is that Tata Sons has always been the backbone of all Tata companies that have been in trouble. And that is the key factor that keeps the whole group together.”“Right now you have a different set of investors in Tata Sons who need funding, they are right to ask, why do we want to invest here? You have to invest in what will deliver and allocate money to the most profitable businesses. So the nature of the group will change. “At the same time, the listing will open new avenues of funding for Tata Sons, providing direct access to public equity markets and a broader base of debt investors, options that are not widely available in its current state, some Tata watchers said.“Why do you think about something that has brought so much value for 150 years? Why do we want to change that?” Tata asked. He said the Trusts will “play a constructive role with regulators, and others, to try to find a solution that preserves Tata’s identity.”Tata also supported the team’s strategy but appeared to question its execution, in comments that were seen as a veiled criticism of Tata Sons chairman N Chandrasekaran.“The strategic approach, as I have said now two or three times, remains the same. Philanthropy on the one hand, building the nation on the other hand. This depends on the leadership, on humanity. This is included in the DNA of the party,” he said. “I have never asked or questioned the direction of what we have done. Sometimes I question the delivery of what we are doing.”“The question is, do we have discipline when we do projects and not guidance? How will projects with a long gestation period succeed if we don’t have discipline? And how will we allocate money to those projects?”“So obviously, the direction is going well, but we also need the discipline to execute on these very large projects,” he said.
Source link
